niemeyjt wrote: ↑Tue Sep 07, 2021 5:28 pm
I guess no government will make promises like that again - or at least not without so many riders to make it useless.
Leaving aside the issue of broken promises - extra money is required. What I object to in the announcement is that NI disproportionately hits the younger and lower-paid who are less likely to benefit from the funding raised.
Personally, given
NI is not hypothecated I would look at two steps - 1) removing the upper limits on payments and 2) merging it with Income Tax.
Perhaps that is the root of the problem. My German tax statements show payments made by me and my employer towards:
Social insurance - pensions
Care insurance
Health insurance
Invalidity insurance
etc.
Each being ring fenced and from my contributions I can calculate for each how much I can draw down in the event of need.
It is not without its problems and some areas (health) have run at a loss for quite a number of years.
I do agree though that the NI construct needs to be revised. Why an upper limit? and why stop collecting NI contributions when you reach 65 (or is it 66 now?)? At least adding it to Income tax would resolve those issues.